Gregory's Server@northernlights @Radical_EgoCom I'll put it on my reading list, but chances are I won't get to it this century. Sigh. Sounds similar to an Against The Grain book I have read. Its theory was that agriculture led to centralization because farmers are easier to conquer, they're tied to the land. Plus, primal civilization probably crashed several times and this was basically a good thing, survivors escaped to the hills.
|
13 comments
@DrDanMarshall @Radical_EgoCom Yes. There must be a balance between securing your own survival and the grotesque levels of inequality we see today. I have no issues with everybody being middle class. @northernlights @Radical_EgoCom Mathematical impossibility, depending on how you define "middle class." Piketty defines the working class as the lowest 50%, middle class as between the 50th and 90th percentiles. But possible to eliminate the impoverished (less than 60% of median income) and the current rich (top 1%), as opposed to the merely well-to-do (top 10% but not in the top 1%). @northernlights @Radical_EgoCom Putting the max wealth at the Value of a Statistical Human Life would do that. Estimates for that value range from $7 mil to $10 mil, $11 mil in net worth needed to be in the top 1%. A wealth tax in that range would be about enough to pay for a UBI at 60% of the median income. @northernlights @Radical_EgoCom Been a while since I've done the math, and getting the tax structure right is non-trivial. Would suck if we got rid of all the multi-millionaires but kept the billionaires. If I remember right, the UBI budget wasn't *quite* enough to lift all Americans out of relative poverty all by itself, but it came damn close. @DrDanMarshall @Radical_EgoCom They still are, in the mountains of Thailand, Laos, Burma, thereabouts. James Scott has a book about them (The Art of Not Being Governed, maybe?) @northernlights @Radical_EgoCom I've been wondering where the maroons have gotten off to, if marronage is still necessary after the end of formal slavery. I suppose a lot of gay kids escaping their parents could be seen as practicing a form of urban marronage. And homelessness in general I suppose. Any other forms of marronage still practiced in the US that you know of? @DrDanMarshall @Radical_EgoCom If marronage is understood to mean escaping unwanted bondage, women escaping abusive marriages. Even American voters escaping a second Trump presidency in 2020. @northernlights @Radical_EgoCom In Haiti, grande marronage meant running away from slavery to a community of fellow runaways in an "illegible" territory, like swamps or mountains. Similar things happened in the antebellum US, but I don't know of any examples with the same "flavor" post-bellum. Slavers generally figured anybody who wanted freedom *that* bad was a hothead, good riddance. @northernlights @Radical_EgoCom There were lesser forms of marronage, like urban marronage. A big city can be almost as illegible as swamps and hills, and when being homeless in the big city is better than whatever hell you have going on at home... I'm just wondering why grande marronage is no longer on the table here in the US. Has the gov't gotten better at "reading" swamps, or are there fewer lives worse than shacking up in a swamp? @northernlights @Radical_EgoCom Some women escaping abusive relationships might wind up homeless, but I would hope most are housed and therefore legible to the gov't. Ideally, it would just be their exes they have to stay illegible from. @DrDanMarshall @Radical_EgoCom Oh, hahaha, Scott wrote Against the Grain |
@northernlights @Radical_EgoCom It would be sad if "adjust your oxygen mask before helping others" would increase inequality and reduce solidarity, but I suppose it makes sense it would.