Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Johannes Ernst

So why is it that Fediverse-based software development projects all need to have a Discord or such?

Actually, I know why that is. What I don't know is whether anybody is working on bringing Discord-like functionality to the Fediverse and if not, why not.

Thoughts? Pointers?

7 comments
Shoq

@J12t That was the direction I was urging Firefish to move in. Most of these forks don’t see any kind of real time chat as important.(I do.) And Matrix may soon be more suitable as a chat protocol,, now that the Vector folks are taking over the moribund Synapse server (always ponderous and buggy). And it would solve the DM problem, too.

LPS

@J12t
Isn't #matrix touted as the federated version of discord..not #activitypub of course

Johannes Ernst

@lps ... and it's even stranger that so many fediverse projects use (closed) Discord for their chat over (more open) Matrix.

Johannes Ernst

@zach protocol-wise, possibly -- although a difference in W3C standard vs foundation. But product-wise: why do I need to leave my fediverse app to group chat? Why isn't it part of the same product?

Zachariah Gibbens

@J12t I'd be happy if it wasn't discord or another closed platform personally but I think that's a good question. I was going to say mastodon doesn't really feel like real time conversation like IRC, Matrix or XMPP does for me, but this conversation is causing me to rethink that notion.

Go Up