Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
daniel:// stenberg://

Please don't make this a new trend. 😕

(issue closed by bot because the user filing the issue has not starred the repository...)

52 comments
Newk

@bagder

If you like the project please consider to like *here* and share *here* and I would be very happy if you leave a comment.

Momo

@Newk
...and don't forget to hit the notification bell.
@bagder

Timothy Wolodzko

@bagder WTAF?! That's literally a Goodhart's law in action.

Skrrp :bisexual_flag:

@bagder I say let it rot. They knew what they were getting into with this behaviour.

Stefan Eissing

@bagder The stars are the bug counter? I always misunderstood!

James Basoo

@bagder Ew, that's gross. Also auto-closing after a certain time is frustrating. I saw one years old issue recently that people are commenting on every month so it doesn't expire.

The other m

@bagder
Naming and shaming seems appropriate to stave off this behaviour!

Moritz Dietz

@bagder Oh boy! That is absolutely annoying and also just strange.

Travis Newton :node:

@bagder GitHub has ruined things. This nonsense never happened on Sourceforge or CodePlex. Or on Bugzilla or Mantis instances.

DELETED

@travis @bagder

So many reasons I use GitLab and not GitHub.

𝘋𝘪𝘳𝘬

@travis @bagder Or on Codeberg, or other public FOSS Git hosting services.

Brodie Robertson

@bagder Surely internet points aren't that important to someones self worth

ck

@BrodieOnLinux
A star on Github costs somewhere between $1 and $0.10 on the clickfarm market, so you can do the math.

@bagder

Pierre Prinetti

@mattb I’m thinking about an auto-reponder in Slack that filters out messages of non-stargazers

DieMadColonizer

@bagder throw eggs at the devs, put them in trash cans, give them swirlies, bully them till they stop

mmu_man

@bagder it's the last thing that would make me want to star a repo… 🤦‍♂️

Thomas Frans 🇺🇦

@bagder How to make me not want to star your project (I literally star every project I find remotely interesting).

Man2Dev :idle:

@bagder when @BrodieOnLinux made the video on how bots closing issues might be problem, I thought isn't he overreacting. I guess I was wrong
youtube.com/watch?v=1lYgB_NHFY

Clemens

@bagder To be fair, the project in question seems to have stopped this. It's an awful practice nonetheless.

Ann Effes

@bagder
Whooot?

You cannot report issues unless you "starred" the repository?

If it helps I can *stare* at it in disbelief for a few minutes.

Paul Taylor

@bagder Christ. What is even the point. I think at that I would be doing my best to find a replacement.

AMS

@bagder Star, comment, report project, bot, and author for abuse.

🔗 David Sommerseth

@bagder This project in question reverted that. And it may even be in violation with GH ToS.

Details: github.com/daeuniverse/dae/iss

tamas 🦀

@popey @bagder Embarrassing it was added in the first place, but at least they shut it down.

popey

@tamas @bagder I think there are real cultural differences the Internet highlights. I can see why someone might think it's a good idea, even if I wouldn't do it myself. 🤷

tamas 🦀

@popey @bagder While that might be true in the general sense, I wouldn’t write this off as a cultural difference. Just a plain bad idea.

Chris [list of emoji]

@bagder

Y'know, most of the time when I report a bug, it's as a contribution to the project. The fix itself is rarely useful to me because I've either patched it myself or worked around it.

soaproot

@bagder I favorited your toot, what do I get now?

Gokul Das

@bagder All these started with the 'stale issues' bot. Closing issues automatically based on activity, instead of its merit is a brain-dead concept, IMO. This tendency arises from the social-media-attention-economy where online activity is projected as a status symbol. By promoting the idea that open issues are bad, they're also conditioning people into performing free labor.

rob salmond (he/him)

@bagder ewww, that's even worse than "join our discord to ask questions".

Schoentoon 🇳🇱🇨🇭

@bagder That seems so much worse than the trend of auto closing issues :/

DELETED

@bagder well that is just gross and I hope their project is absorbed by a better team.

DELETED

@bagder Wait until "Github influencers" starts being used as a term, then we'll know it's over :blobcatgooglyholdingitsheadinitshands:

🏳️‍🌈🎃🇧🇷Luana🇧🇷🎃🏳️‍🌈 :verified:

@bagder that’s worse than those bots that close an issue if you haven’t talked in a week, smh

Hänzi Pōtter

@bagder would they roll back the fix if the user would **un-star** the project later on? asking for a friend 😅

Edvin Malinovskis

@bagder I get the appeal of filtering requests for free work, by some minimal friction. But GitHub starts? Really? 😬

𝘋𝘪𝘳𝘬

@bagder "Your support is appreciated but we will ignore it."

th𝟘ms

@bagder more than 50% of the people watching this repo have not starred it. What are you waiting for?

Go Up