Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Marcus Hutchins :verified:

I do wonder how many people are staying on Twitter due to follower count alone. Having had an account for over a decade, I'd have previously estimated about 20% of my followers were dead accounts. Based on now leaving and making new accounts on other platforms, my estimate is closer to 90%.

As a blogger I've always known only like 1% of people who retweet/like a post actually clicked the link and read the article, but I assumed that was just a social media thing. Having experimented with basically every other platform, I learned it's more likely that a significant number of Twitter engagements are fake, and those that aren't don't really care enough to read your work, they'll just give you a retweet/like for appearances.

25 comments
Darren :unverified:

@malwaretech Meh, I'm still on Twitter because people I want to follow are there.

katrintheresa

@malwaretech Great question. I was not on Twitter for 7 years for followers— it held a different type of “gravity.” A mystery still.

cultdev

@malwaretech yeah i’m new here but i’m actually astounded by how active the conversation is, even at very low numbers. if i ever reached the same follow/follower counts i had on twitter i think it’d be overwhelming

John Sundman

@malwaretech A few years ago I had nearly 10k followers. Assuming 2k dead accounts and 5k accounts that rarely posted, that still left 3k with whom I had some potential contact, 100's of quasi- regulars.

All those numbers are way down now. I haven't found anything to replace it, although I do use mstdn, facebook, even linked in.

Trying to recruit followers to my substack, but it's a challenge. Oh well.

hybrid havoc

@malwaretech I think the higher potential for grift exists with a platform, the more fake or like-fake engagements will exist.

Pandora Amethyst

@malwaretech the reason Elon says he wants to charge the $2 per account is valid. Hackers inflate their egos and their reach by using bot accounts to follow their main accounts, and their friends accounts. They want to feel worthy of love so they falsely seek it online. If he did make that fee a ton of hackers probably would come here with their bots. Not one of them would be willing to pay half a million dollars a month (l know some accounts that have 170k bots) but they will probably come here

Dan

@malwaretech Twitter has its appeal and the only reason I am still there is certain content. I've not been able to replicate my tried and trusted sources on any other platform. With that being said, the quality of content is deteriorating quickly with it becoming difficult to sift through the trash. If more of the Twitter folks found their way here, it would not even be a comparison.

Ferdi F. Zebua 🌏

@malwaretech

Indonesians stay on Twitter because Indonesians aren't anywhere else.¹ Complaints to Indonesian businesses & services still work on Twitter.

Indo subcultures still congregate on Twt. No one calls it X nor pay for Blue/premium/whatev. Elon drama does not affect them/us.

Until X becomes fully pay2play someday maybe.

__
¹…or on Fb. Ppl on Twitter publicly call FB ppl drama queens. Vice versa ppl on Fb call Twt ppl drama queens.

Also Instagram & TikTok to a smaller degree.

@malwaretech

Indonesians stay on Twitter because Indonesians aren't anywhere else.¹ Complaints to Indonesian businesses & services still work on Twitter.

Indo subcultures still congregate on Twt. No one calls it X nor pay for Blue/premium/whatev. Elon drama does not affect them/us.

Until X becomes fully pay2play someday maybe.

kkeller

@FerdiZ @malwaretech Musk will eventually do something to hurt your community. It would be good to be prepared for that eventuality.

DELETED

@malwaretech I like that you have a large enough dataset to draw some plausible conclusions, especially ones that jive with my assumptions, hah

DELETED

@malwaretech the part I found the most odd were folks that claimed follower counts didn't matter were the ones most concerned about them.

J Miller

@malwaretech

Have definitely been told by an organization that they need to stay there due to 10s of thousands of followers. A tool that makes it clear just how much those followers are no longer active would be super helpful. An argument for deleting one’s account, not just going inactive, is that people will continue to interpret inactive followers as reach.

Dakota Reynolds

@malwaretech I have a friend who relies heavily on a community they've built over the past several years and don't want to/are afraid to try building it back up elsewhere.

John Breen

@malwaretech When I was using Deadbird, I would routinely block most people who followed me, after taking a look at their profile and posting history, because they did not look like real people anyway. That's one way to keep your follower count low 😎

Richard W. Woodley NO THREADS 🇨🇦🌹🚴‍♂️📷 🗺️

@malwaretech
Do you ever wonder how it is possible for anyone to read all the tweets of the supposedly thousands of people they are "following".

Judi Anderson

@malwaretech

Yanno, sometimes, I've already read the article.🤷‍♀️

Erotic Mythology (hire me) 💖

@malwaretech I am not active on Twitter any more but I did keep my account in small part because of the follower count, yes, even though engagement has been shit. But two more important reasons are the people who are still there and that I have yet to figure out if my tweet archive still works when I delete my tweets. I used a parser that supposedly downloaded everything in HTML and MD format but I dunno if it's easily searchable like the archive that still connects to Twitter 😕

Dwight Williams (💉 x6) + 😷

@malwaretech I find myself removing one (probably fake) follower a day on the HellBirdSite. I don't imagine I have a great following there. There are lots of like-minded people who - whether they know or care about me or not - I want to see succeed and survive the process over there.

Quinn Blueheart

@malwaretech Twitter(x)’s new privacy policy starts 9/29. If all goes as plans, I’ll be off Twitter before then. Followers were part of what kept me there, but also I have many author friends there. Sadly, many of hose friends haven’t made the leap to Medium. The writing community on here is still growing, but I wish it would grow more quickly.

Dr. Jorge Caballero

@malwaretech I agree. I'll add that upside of twitter for myself, and for many scientists, was the potential impact. The small % of actual persons who actually read the content and weren't hate following— members of that tiny cohort were oftentimes well-connected and in a position to do something with the information

Tommy Thorn

@malwaretech I don’t personally care one iota about my follower count, but I do enjoy interactions. Twitter was a barely net positive, but after the sink arrived I neutered my account (removed all the people I followed). I stopped just short of deleting it as I like to refer back to old posts. However I don’t visit there anymore.

Neel Chauhan

@malwaretech A decent amount of my followers came to mastodon, but not all.

I also set my twitter account to private. I might check sometimes, but very little when compared to mastodon/tiktok.

I got CONSERVATIVE ads despite a mostly liberal and LGBTQ+ feed. it's basically truth social but with actual users.

what compaq was to PCs, twitter is to social media. Carly fiorina killed HP, and elon musk is killing twitter

Pär Björklund

@malwaretech I tend to retweet some articles I don't read because I like the author and want to boost them.

Go Up