Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Les Orchard

Gruber says: "...the idea that administrators of Mastodon/Fediverse instances should pledge to preemptively block Facebook’s imminent Twitter-like ActivityPub service (purportedly named Threads) strikes me as petty and deliberately insular. ... to me this feels like convicting Facebook of a pre-crime."

To me, this take feels obtuse to the point of intention - or at least self-parody. Smells a bit like the whole "paradox of tolerance" folks like to shop around in debates.

Surely you can't possibly be unaware that Meta (née Facebook) already has a rich history of acting badly, that many folks switched to alternatives like Mastodon as a response to that, and many now express wariness & outright revulsion to that same bad actor wandering into a new party?

My dear sweet summer child, don't be a doofus.

daringfireball.net/linked/2023

4 comments
Les Orchard

"The whole point of ActivityPub as an open protocol is to turn Twitter/Instagram-like social networking into something more akin to email: truly open."

The point of an open protocol is to help folks build what they want to build. Not an obligation to welcome everyone into their house.

If I have a full beer keg and you have a tap that fits it, that doesn't necessarily mean you're invited to my barbecue.

Christopher Wood

@lmorchard Point of order, open like email where the small players have deliverability issues to the big providers and the anti-spam arms war spirals up (in price) with every year?

Chris [list of emoji]

@lmorchard

"Sure, they've gotten drunk and trashed the place at every single party they've been invited to in living memory, but that doesn't mean they'll do it at *ours*."

Luci for dyeing

@lmorchard if I set up an email server, spam blocking all of facebook’s servers would be the first thing I do there too.

Go Up