Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Alex McLean

I really wish there was a culture in free/open source software of actually telling the person who made the thing when you do something good/interesting/cool/weird with it, used it in a workshop/teaching. It's super nice+motivating when I hear about tidal being used on a course or something, but it's generally only by chance.
I guess it's another case of people adopting the at-a-distance customer-supplier relationship of commercial/proprietary software, when free/open source _should_ take a friendlier approach

22 comments
Dook

@yaxu I was just thinking about this yesterday with an open source project hosted on github. Often the only way you can communicate with the creators about a project is through issues and bug reports, which doesn't really feel appropriate for discussions.

Alex McLean

@dook Yes it would be great to have a button for this kind of humane feedback on github/gitlab! Bug reports are helpful, but I sometimes find feature requests massively demotivating, e.g. when they come across as entitled..

Dook

@yaxu I looked into it, and there's a tab in github for discussions! It just isn't enabled by default, probably a new feature too. I sure didn't know about it, so I'm going to go and add it to some of my projects!

Weiming Hu

@dook @yaxu you have a very good point. Issuing a ticket should not be the only cause of communication.

danstowell

@yaxu Rather a leap to label it as "customer-supplier", IMHO: I experience it more as "leaving things in the street" / "finding things in the street"

Alex McLean

@danstowell yep that's fair.. somehow wish the street could be a bit more social tho!

Charles 𝄢 H

@yaxu @danstowell

One time, I left some stuff out with a sign that said "free" and the person who took it wrote "thank you" on the sign.

aldroid

@danstowell @yaxu by this analogue i think most of the things i open source can be described as fly tipping :D

mike_hales 💔*!?¿*

@yaxu
Sparks this thought.. In federated wiki, if somebody forks your page you know about it - the flag on your origin page displays a tag <Older/newer> showing where others are at with their usage of your source. This 'neighborhood' feature makes fedwiki an 'awareness engine'.

Doesn't the opensource world have equivalent machinery? Maybe an inventor might create a wiki page for any invention. And others could 'subscribe' by forking the page into their own wiki log of adoptions.

DELETED

@yaxu I've heard plenty stories of authors getting mail from unknown people thanking them for their work. Mention ways of contacting you on your home page, we'll do the rest :) Thank you!

OpenComputeDesign

@yaxu Just recently, I was reading the foreword of a book from over a hundred years ago, in which the author was thanking everyone for their letters of appreciation for their previous books. And I couldn't help but think that with how "interconnected" and "social" everything is now, there should be more of that than ever, but it honestly feels like there's less.

DELETED

@OpenComputeDesign In that vein, I recall some free software projects praise the contributors within the new release communiqués, a heartfelt practice and worthy practice when done sincerely. @yaxu

supernov

@yaxu I tend to send an email sometimes to a support address if they have them to thank them, many say it made their Friday. :) And I also tip often when I use something regularly, both not often done indeed unfortunately.

octopus

@yaxu I never encountered this in the wild, but supposedly there used to be a genre of shareware called "postcard-ware" where to register you just sent a postcard to the developer. that was it. then the dev would put a pin in the map they hang up by their desk I guess?

I always thought that sounded cool.

DELETED

@yaxu often i have wanted to tell people on GitHub that their software was great but there is no place to tell them unless i make an issue. It does seem like the whole paradigm is set to be so distant and transaction based

LisPi

@yaxu It does seem uncommon to do that, though I've seen some libraries with lists of use-cases pointer to user projects.

lee

@yaxu bring back “postcardware”!

Paul Mason

@yaxu It's kind of standard behaviour in the open source game engine world - people tend to naturally form a community around the projects and show off what they've done. It's probably just a result of it being more visibly creative though?

David Eccles 🌻🩹🩹🩹🛡️🩹

@yaxu related: I just reviewed a paper which provided citations for all of the software tools, but none of the datasets that were used to validate their workflow. I found it to be an odd disconnect.

Jonathan Hartley

@yaxu I drive-by liked this toot yesterday. Today I came back to look it up and share it too. I intend to be the change I wish to see! Thank you.

Sometimes when I've done this in the past, I've imagined that the creators of successful projects would be too busy to care or acknowledge otherwise contentless thank-yous from users. But in practice, I have discerned no upper bound to the project size for which authors are gleefully grateful.

Jonathan Hartley

@yaxu More, it is common for amazing but not viral projects like "colout", which I have used gleefully every day for years, when I thank the creator, they tell me that it is so rare or unique to receive thanks that they consider the project unused.

Go Up