Gregory's Server@silmathoron @xpil it also reduces the usability and visibility of IDN websites to users with an "interface that uses roman alphabet".
Why *should* https://žvižgač.si be only shown as https://xn--viga-jua78dc.si/ to them? This effectively makes them less likely to click. In other words, it *punishes* websites for using IDN domains.
Not to mention, what does it even mean a "language interface that uses roman alphabet"? It's UTF/unicode mostly anyway.
And consider English words like "naïve".
@silmathoron @xpil not to mention, it's basically saying "let's protect the English speakers from such scams; we simply can't be bothered to care that these scams also affect speakers of other languages and uses of non-ASCII scripts".
Which is... very meh.