Generative AI is making our language and communication poorer. It does this not just by outputting its own garbage but also because now we have AI making arbitrary determinations of what words and phrases we *humans* are or aren't allowed to use.
Top-level
Generative AI is making our language and communication poorer. It does this not just by outputting its own garbage but also because now we have AI making arbitrary determinations of what words and phrases we *humans* are or aren't allowed to use. 31 comments
Imagine coming up with a machine that effectively gets to decide how humans are "supposed to" write and speak. Reduction to a mean pollutes the source for everyone. The idiocracification of humanity continues apace. @artemis This is the opposite of the curb cut effect. They're harming everyone by repressing autistic people. @foolishowl @artemis "on the suggestion of tech companies we have decided to raise all curbs by 10-20 cm." @foolishowl @artemis They're harming everyone directly. It's just automated anti intellectualism. @artemis sounds like a white supremacy machine tbh. prescriptivism has always been racist. @artemis I've always trended towards a high vocabulary — which, I might add, is something that *used* to be considered an extremely positive thing that was pushed to be grown as much as possible in kids. And then there's how I basically *had* to go out of my way to learn the word "malicious" back in second grade to counteract some bullshit comebacks my teachers had about the boys teasing me. >_< @artemis Being compared to the average of slop data scraped off the internet in order to be "human" is incredibly awful. @virtualbri @artemis @VATVSLPR @virtualbri @artemis You forgot to mention *highly educated* people from developing countries because that's the population that gets those jobs. @artemis It’s worst in the form of AI but I also hate it in the form of increasingly opinionated “grammar and style” checkers built into every email and doc editing software now. If I couch a phrase in any but the most blunt terms I get little squiggles telling me that I’m communicating wrong. Computers should not be telling humans how they’re allowed to use language. Humans should not be building programs which crush out variance and expressivity in language. @artemis IIRC there was a huge thing on African Twitter about this: a lot of the LLM training/tagging was done by Nigerian workers (underpaid ghost labour) and Nigerian English is gorgeously full of expressive and specific terms which introduces a bias in LLMs to use those words like delve, devoid, etc, and AI checkers were updated in turn to look for those as markers and people automatically assuming stuff was written by LLMs. @artemis Typically I would add a short preamble stating that I am proud of having a rich vocabulary and that I can prove it live. |
Tell you what: "devoid" was definitely a word I knew and used in elementary school.
Am I normal? Nah, not really.
Am I human? I'm pretty damn sure I am, yeah.