Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
Pierre Bourdon

@lina that video linked in Wedson's retirement mail is... damning, to say the least. Wow. And the fact that this is apparently just acceptable behavior in that community...

19 comments
Karl

@delroth @lina God, that's textbook gatekeeping.

Whoever uttered those words should be deeply ashamed (but they're not, I'm sure).

40whirl

@karl @delroth @lina apparently that's who maintains ext4 code :blobcat_dundundun:

Karl

@40whirl @delroth @lina You'd imagine someone maintaining such a widely used filesystem would be interested in the properties of a memory-safe language, especially given ext4's track record on the matter.

40whirl

@karl @delroth @lina i mean, even if they actively hate rust and people writing rust, they should at least use valid points in an argument...

Greg Brooks

@karl @40whirl @delroth @lina He doesn’t want to learn. Doesn’t want to admit he’s not an all knowing gray beard.

Imikoy

@delroth@mastodon.delroth.net It felt like the output of active-on-twitter US conservatives...

edit: the one-word description here is "reactionary"

Daniel Leigh

@delroth @lina what is it with prominent C developers insisting that there is no reason to learn anything new and that C is the only good way to write software? It isn't just kernel people, this is a huge issue on the userland side of open source too. This gatekeeping is super toxic, and leads to dramatically worse software overall.

P4

@danielleigh @delroth @lina it's not just C programmers, I've seen a very similar sentiment in other places too. To me all their arguments come off as "I've spent a long time to learn this difficult thing and I want to feel superior because of it, I can't do that if you make the difficult thing easier, so stop".

Pierre Bourdon

@p4 @danielleigh @lina which is especially funny coming from C programmers because... there's barely anything to learn, it's not a difficult language, and "experienced" C programmers aren't particularly good at avoiding the footguns that beginners also encounter.

Daniel Leigh

@delroth @p4 @lina C isn't a difficult language ... to memorize. In actual use the C++ that C programmers hate so much is massively simpler (as is Rust and every other higher level language.) Which isn't to say C++ is good, it inherits all of C's flaws and adds some, but many C programmers seem to take pride in using the least capable tool that is at all practical in what feels like a mix of elitism and toxic masculinity.

Alyssa Rosenzweig

@danielleigh @delroth @p4 @lina imho, Rust > C > C++.

sincerely,
a very tired C programmer

DELETED

@p4 @danielleigh @delroth @lina You can see this behaviour from companies, that feel threatened by innovation, too.

Charadon

@delroth @lina As far as I know, not a lot of people like the guy who's making an ass of himself (He's the maintainer of ext4 iirc, his name is Ted Ts’o) and he's really only kept around because he maintains ext4.

If you noticed, no one clapped after he was done with his hissy fit ;)

Mia Luna Tearmoon

@delroth @lina completely ignoring the speaker's points and just talking over them like that feels incredibly rude to me, especially on stage

Rafael Martins

@delroth @lina not the biggest rust fan myself, but that is *really* messed up. there's no excuse for that :(

balseiro

@rafaelmartins @delroth @lina with all due respect, what is all this “I’m not a Rust fan” about? I’m not a coder so it sounds strange to me. I mean, programming languages are tools, you don’t need to be a fan of one or another, just use it when it fits. I’m not a fan of my dishwasher, but it does a fine job at its thing.

Rafael Martins

@balseiro @delroth @lina heh. you are not wrong... as a professional software engineer I write code in whatever language I'm paid to, like, literally any language that is better suited for the job. The "not a rust fan" just means that if I'm starting a personal project it is unlikely that I'd pick Rust as a primary language for it, as I have more fun coding on some other languages, and personal projects need to be fun :D I don't try to prevent anyone to code in rust neither advocate against it.

Akseli :quake_verified:​ :kde:

@delroth @lina the video made me want to learn rust out of spite lol

Go Up