Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
Jason Evangelho

@vkc I've been a Plex (and PlexAmp) user for 4 years. Is it worth the effort to switch over? Do you have any videos comparing the two?

11 comments
𝚝𝚓𝚠

@killyourfm @vkc I want to know the same thing because I’ve been thinking of switching.

Daniël Franke 🏳️‍🌈

@killyourfm @vkc

I never used PlexAmp, so can't say anything about it, but I switched over this year. It works a charm, on par with plex, at least for me.

But the main reasons I switched are:

- Plex not working when the internet is down. All my media is on my local network, why do I need internet to watch it:
- Plex definitely saving my media consumption history. As shown by them sending mails to everyone saying what their friends did.
- Local media seems less and less a priority for plex.

Jason Evangelho

@ainmosni @vkc Thanks for the feedback and your reasoning. Appreciate it! Plex not working when the internet goes down is an annoying pain point.

As for the other reasons: you can opt completely out of sharing any history in your account settings (and I encourage my friends to do this). And once you turn off discovery and pin your local media libraries, I never even consider that Plex cares about anything else.

Daniël Franke 🏳️‍🌈

@killyourfm @vkc

For me the final points are more hints that they are going to enshittify more and more over time. Simply said, I don't trust the company anymore.

ManMachine

@killyourfm @vkc PlexAmp is irreplaceable. JellyFin as a music listening solution is vastly lacking in that regard (at least for me and last time I’ve checked it).

Jason Evangelho

@manmachine @vkc That's helpful, thanks! I happen to love PlexAmp especially for all of its "Sonic" abilities. But I don't mind keeping it (lifetime Plex pass) and switching to Jellyfin for everything else if it's compelling enough.

ManMachine

@killyourfm @vkc For movies/shows Jellyfin seems to be on par as I understand.

Veronica Explains

@killyourfm If you're using Plex for your audio, Jellyfin probably isn't full featured enough yet. Jellyfin in particular doesn't have offline play of your audio library. For me that's a dealbreaker as I can't go into airplane mode. (insert iPod snark here)

There is a third party Jellyfin audio player called Finamp which is better, but offline play is buggy and album based only. Plex likely outperforms just because it's a more mature ecosystem.

No videos yet on it but I'm considering it!

Jason Evangelho

@vkc Thanks Veronica, appreciate your reply.
Time allowing, I might just spin it up and compare both for awhile.

Go Up