Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Mastodon's posts Post Back to profile
Top-level
Greg Hills

@sam @maegul @mastodonmigration @stuart @vruz @snarfed.org @snarfed

> "It's one of the servers in the network."

No, it is not.

Bluesky is not part of the ActivityPub network, any more than are Twitter or Facebook.

cathode.church/fedi-scraper-co

I could actually kinda-sorta-maybe get behind a bridge like this, IF IT WAS OPT IN. This is not opt in. It does not even respect flags that say hoovering up a Mastodon person's or instance's data is OK with that person or that instance.

13 February at 4:10 | Wall-to-wall | Open on mastodon.social
5 comments
maegul

@winterknell @sam @mastodonmigration @stuart @vruz @snarfed.org @snarfed

I don’t know.

If it can connect or be bridged then is it not “the network”?

Not sure that there’s anything special about ActivityPub. To the point that it seems dangerous to emphasise a formal/nominative distinction rather than a functional one. Ie, the issue should be more about what the protocol does rather than its name.

If mechanics are effectively the same then bsky is really just a big instance no?

13 February at 5:02 | Open on hachyderm.io
Greg Hills

@maegul @sam @mastodonmigration @stuart @vruz @snarfed.org @snarfed

Ask MySpace about Facebook's bridge.

My objection is not addressed to the protocols, but to the ethics. Public posts on Mastodon and on Bluesky are easily scraped. That does not mean that any arsehole can just go ahead and bot-scrape it and pass it on.

As a Masto instance, indieweb.social is welcome to receive whatever is not blocked from them, but not to pass it on wholesale beyond the edge of the Fediverse.

13 February at 5:22 | Open on mastodon.social
maegul

@winterknell @sam @mastodonmigration @stuart @vruz @snarfed.org @snarfed

I don't know about that bridge.

But my point is that "scraping" and then "passing on beyond the fediverse" aren't necessarily clear or helpful criteria.

If fediverse="uses ActivityPub" then that allows for a lot of stuff including what is effectively "scraping" (eg, kbin is effectively a search engine for masto content AFAIU). Staying "within fediverse" can be pretty arbitrary then.

13 February at 6:35 | Open on hachyderm.io
Greg Hills

@maegul @sam @mastodonmigration @stuart @vruz @snarfed.org @snarfed

That Bluesky doesn't use ActivityPub is a pretty clear indication that it's "beyond the Fediverse". The fact that I can't block Bluesky but can, and now have blocked, both indieweb and snarfed, is a pretty clear indication of the boundary.

That the guy thinks forcing "opt out" on people is acceptable is the clearest indication of all. I'm not opposed to reach, but I'm opposed to this guy's approach.

My profile's Privacy-and-Reach page, with all the boxes checked allowing my profile and posts to roam.
13 February at 7:03 | Open on mastodon.social
margrim

@maegul @winterknell @sam @mastodonmigration @stuart @vruz @snarfed.org @snarfed

That bridge is important. Those who ignore history are doomed to repeat it.

Back in the early aughts, when Facebook expanded to the public, 'everyone' was on MySpace. It is improbable to organically acquire the users of an established social network (particularly one so liked) if you're walled off. So they created a bridge (bot) connecting users to friends still on MySpace while siphoning users.

13 February at 8:48 | Open on mastodon.social
Go Up