Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
Baldur Bjarnason

@mhoye I mean, what the Stanford professor said about lay-offs being a really bad idea that usually harms both the company and the laid off employees is still true

Everything he said about why it happened is bullshit, of course. Unless you mentally substitute "social contagion" with "greed-inspired idiocy" or something 🙂

(This is a recurring phenomenon in biz/economics studies. They can often demonstrate specific negative outcomes, but almost never positive outcomes or ultimate causes)

17 comments
Baldur Bjarnason

@mhoye But that Blind post is really interesting and does seem to support what a lot of us were thinking at the time.

mhoye

@baldur I suppose that's true, but "layoffs are very bad and have awful human consequences" followed by "enh, y'know, sometimes these things just happen and they're nobody's fault", when they are in fact specifically the fault of some specific people for specific reasons is just giving those people intellectual and moral shelter and helping them escape accountability.

Jeff Abrahamson

@baldur @mhoye I wonder to what extent his conclusions about effects on health extend to Europe. The context in the U.S. is far more brutal. I'm sure it's not great for people here, either, but I'm reluctant to assume the same health consequences.

Schroedinger

@jeff_abrahamson @baldur @mhoye I think the impact is probably similar here in Europe. Especially if you are in a niche market - where there are only a few companies who can really use your skills.

Davida Taylor

@jeff_abrahamson @baldur @mhoye
Oh yes, it is happening here in Europe as well, At least here in Germany. Worse is watching the Auto Industry implode, taking out of tech workers and skilled workers too. Sad.

Geoff Berner

@baldur @mhoye if you think it's "idiocy" that their side carefully, secretly and effectively organized and coordinated their attacks on your side, that might be an insight into why you keep losing to their side.

Sylvain Drapeau

@Geoffberner @baldur @mhoye

You talk like it's a war waged on equal grounds by armies of like power and resolve...

What if someone was tipped off in advance of the layoffs. Then what? How do you "defend" against this attack?

Sylvain Drapeau

@mhoye @Geoffberner @baldur

Good point.

I don't know how it works in the USA, but in Canada, unions in tech jobs are mostly non-existent. Lots of work to be done before it's an effective protection.

tyil

@axnxcamr@mstdn.ca @mhoye@mastodon.social @Geoffberner@zeroes.ca @baldur@toot.cafe USA has practically no unions because that's a communist idea and Americans generally prefer to just suffer tremendously than use an idea created by The Enemy.

Aaron

@mhoye @axnxcamr @Geoffberner @baldur I would also take this opportunity to mention that unions are unnecessary if you work for a worker coop. It's like the union *is* the employer. It also reduces the wealth inequality problem, since the shareholders are the workers instead of wealthy rent-collectors. Imagine if our employers actually worked for us.

Aaron

@mhoye @axnxcamr @Geoffberner @baldur (But yes, if you can't work for a coop, unionization is the right choice.)

Geoff Berner

@axnxcamr @baldur @mhoye that's kind of my point. The problem here is that many employees believe their company's purpose is to solve tech problems, when the actual animating purpose of those in charge is to lord it over people like them. The tech solutions were always a means to that end. You can't resist something that you won't first acknowledge as reality.

Sylvain Drapeau

@Geoffberner @baldur @mhoye

I had misread your original point then, as we now are in total agreement!

McNeely

@baldur @mhoye I had always assumed "social contagion" was mean to be a semi polite euphemism for some of these guys decided it needed to happen for their wallets and then it became a reality bc everyone else could point to others doing it.

Kevin Granade

@baldur @mhoye the only way "social contagion" fits the narrative is in the upswing, "everyone is hiring so the predictions must be right".

Go Up