Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
John Overholt

Optometrist George Mayerle’s 1907 multicultural eye chart is a fabulous piece of graphic design in its own right. circulatingnow.nlm.nih.gov/202

28 comments
DELETED

@overholt maybe but I can only see the bottom line

varx/social

@overholt I'm fascinated by the presence of numeric digits in the symbols column. I guess even the illiterate are likely to know numbers!

Hyphinett

@overholt wouldn't you say the inclusion of an American flag and only an American flag shows a bias towards a certain culture? Not that it's not cool and well designed either, or that it can't be multicultural and still show bias.

wb x64

@BreoganHackett @overholt it's definitely not perfect (some of the symbols are ambiguous, like sideways vs upright star, or pear vs avocado(?), and the rows are similar size but not similar complexity so the results won't be consistent between languages) but as a rough tool that doesn't depend on knowing English letters it's great

Hyphinett

@wilbr @overholt again I wasn't critiquing it's validity as a test just trying to raise the point that what one person might call multicultural is still impacted by where they come from in the world.

Potato ENTHUSIAST

@BreoganHackett @wilbr @overholt it's pretty i guess. But not functional (ambiguity) and not inclusive (American flag in the middle, danger)

/dev/urandom

@overholt neat!

the actual russian optometric chart looks kinda similar, but restricts itself to 7 letters that all snugly fit their boxes -- presumably to make sure that a person with poor eyesight can't "cheat" by recognizing a letter like А or Х by its overall shape

DELETED

@overholt Imagine what happens when a future culture tries to use this as a Rosetta stone.

Bonkers

@weilawei @overholt

Imagine an optometrist trying to understand what the patient says

🌼 Dagnabbit, Pascaline! 🌼

@overholt Wow, this is such a great chart! I love it, thanks for posting ❤

mrchan

@overholt Presumably because there is no simple alphabet list for Chinese, the characters used seem to be phrases, possibly taken from a newspaper or signage. For example, the second row 萬國寶通銀行 (then written right to left) is International Banking Corporation (now Citibank)

Matei Matthias Covrigus 🥨

@mrchan @overholt
Also date
<missing number >年
十月
廿八日

Virginicus

@overholt First time I’ve seen an eye chart with an actual eye.

OliverUv

@overholt first column for English, second column for German

Bjornsdottirs

@overholt Latin is represented twice - once for English/French, and once for what I'd probably call German (Fraktur).

Yoav Lavi

@overholt That Hebrew / Yiddish one spells "Pain" (כאב) (in Hebrew) on the fourth row from the bottom

verity, in a pantry near you

@overholt there's so much in this chart! (why the distinction between the blackletter and typewriter font columns? also why are the chinese characters written in three different fonts?!)

Idle Lifting

@overholt Putting ו and ז right next to each other like that is the real test lol

Matei Matthias Covrigus 🥨

@overholt
I actually can real all of them :dy218:
With some difficulty on the second row. Is that what they call “Gothic alphabet“?

zodarr

@overholt This is most interesting. Didn't thought of this kind of sheet till now.

🌟ジギーくん

@overholt Chinese speakers taking the Japanese eyesight test be like: proletariat

Go Up