Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Yogthos's posts Post Back to profile
Top-level
m0xEE

@yogthos It wasn't workers revolution that overthrown the tsar, he was already not in power. They've overthrown the interim government. Other than that, the article seems neutral and nice. At least it's not whitewashing Stalin, who brought all the tsarist practices back, including the new serfdom, so the workers and especially the peasants got the worst of both worlds.
But yeah, White Terror is just as real as the Red one.

14 Nov 2022 at 13:09 | Wall-to-wall | Open on social.librem.one
4 comments
Yogthos

@m0xee the revolution took over a decade to mature. Revolutions are not singular events, but a long and a complex process.

14 Nov 2022 at 13:16 | Open on mas.to
m0xEE

@yogthos That's true!
I am left-leaning myself, but as the one born in the Soviet Union, I can't stand some parts of the Soviet mythos, The Great October Revolution is one of those. It makes it look like Bolsheviks were the only power responsible for stripping the Tsar of his powers — it's simply not true. The Left would sound way more credible if they stopped pushing it. The article may look biased because of that headline, while in fact it isn't — that was my point.

14 Nov 2022 at 13:30 | Open on social.librem.one
Yogthos

@m0xee Russia went through a bourgeoisie taking power in 1905, and then being finally overthrown in 1917.

Of course there were many different factions fighting for power as the monarchy collapsed.

The reason people focus on the Bolsheviks is that this was the faction that represented the workers and the peasants.

From socialist perspective, the entire process that culminated in Bolsheviks taking power was the revolution.

14 Nov 2022 at 13:51 | Open on mas.to
m0xEE

@yogthos Yeah, I get it. The October Revolution was important for Bolsheviks, but it was not what ended the monarchy, this was: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/February
The Bolsheviks weren't the only acting power and not even the only socialist power. I think that this is a very important detail that is often overlooked or somehow diminished in the Soviet history, while the importance of October events is overblown 🤷

14 Nov 2022 at 14:06 | Open on social.librem.one
Go Up