Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
Deadly Headshot

@grishka
Gender should be a freeform textbox, not a dropdown...

11 comments
Gregory

@dheadshot why not a file upload field that accepts files up to a megabyte

wakest ⁂

@grishka @dheadshot I second this request for it to be an open text field, if tinder can do it so can smithereen

Gregory

@liaizon @dheadshot this isn't displayed anywhere in the profile, it's only used to select strings (write on his/her wall) and inflect the name in Russian. Making it a text field would defeat this only purpose.

Gregory

@liaizon @dheadshot and I don't have it in Tinder 🤔
There used to be two of these radio button groups for "I am" and "I like", the "I like" is now sexual orientation, so that's indeed new.

wakest ⁂

@grishka @dheadshot as someone who is Non Binary and specifically does not go by He nor She having a drop down between those is frustrating every time I come across one. I think at the very least you could select from the list at pronoun.is/ if a drop down seems entirely necessary to you.

Gregory

@liaizon @dheadshot there is a third option of "not specified" actually. But I might add something like "I identify as" when I'll be making profile fields.

Gregory

@liaizon @dheadshot also pronouns are English only — not very good for internationalization. For example I've yet to see a Russian person who would prefer a non-standard pronoun.

wakest ⁂

@grishka @dheadshot was just in Berlin for most of last year and many of the people I was spending time with there were using alternative pronouns in non English languages. Portuguese, German and Spanish specifically. I know a few Russian speakers (Kazakh and Kyrgyz) who have been interviewing folks in the Russian sphere about this issue too.

Gregory

@liaizon @dheadshot but the thing is, how do you translate such pronouns between languages? And, in Russian again, certain words, like verbs in past tense, change suffixes based on the gender:
M: Иван оставил комментарий
F: Анастасия оставила комментарий
There's no gender-neutral form. There's "neutral" grammatical gender (with suffix -о) but it's never used with people. Some people get around this by writing constructs like "оставил(а)", but that just feels sloppy.

Gregory

@liaizon @dheadshot actually I only now noticed that Mastodon is doing this exact thing lol

Go Up