Email or username:

Password:

Forgot your password?
Top-level
mcc

- Firefox can't show image previews when selecting attachments (because of "security", somehow)

- Often, when I direct a program to open a new window, GNOME refuses to let the program do it, and instead opens the window at the back of the stack and shows a top-of-screen notification letting me know there's a new window (I guess also "security")

- Just fresh weird stuff happening at random intervals. Since last week, when I right click in Firefox, I can't click on the menu. It's happening RN

120 comments
mcc

I can use even a very poorly functioning OS because the OS, to me, is just a thin support system that allows a web browser to run. Linux is not succeeding well at this very minimal goal.

mcc

Note: I assume that I will get responses to these posts (okay, I was GOING to say that, but I have got two such responses so far, I didn't even get to finish typing the thread) saying I wouldn't have problems if I didn't use Ubuntu. *I don't believe you!* Using a different distro means yanking an arm on a slot machine. MAYBE I get a functioning system. MAYBE it gets worse! And the cost of *trying* is a few days of intensive work and maybe screwing up my daily-use computer.

Michael T Babcock

@mcc Fedora live image. No install just try and see. YMMV of course.

Josh Simmons

@mcc only one of those issues is a ubuntu problem anyway. then there's a few wayland ones, and i guess the last one is just firefox being broken. it's certainly a game of choose your broken, or perhaps roll the dice and have the broken chosen for you.

mcc

@dotstdy I'm not using Wayland. At least one of the issues is a Snap issue.

Josh Simmons

@mcc the "popups opening in the background" is an xwayland issue, unless there's a specific bonus problem with your configuration, hurray for a rare dice roll. the firefox attachment one is because you're using snap indeed (which is arguably a ubuntu thing because snap is ubuntu only madness).

DELETED

@mcc gnome tweaks might help with the backgrounded windows

Oblomov

@dotstdy @mcc yep, the forced snapification of everything (and especially firefox) is the main reason why I won't be installing Ubuntu anywhere anymore. Fool me once and all that. Pity because it used to be the distro I could put on machine I didn't want to get handsy with. Oh well, back to Debian 12 even for non-power users it seems.

dcbaok

@mcc @dotstdy yeah any firefox brokenness on ubuntu I blame on snap first until proven otherwise

cliziə

@mcc before trying another distro just try another DE, they can be swapped without switching distro

v̾i̾t̾r̾i̾o̾l̾i̾x̾

@mcc Heh, I was going to say "try Ubuntu, it's worked pretty seemlessly on my laptop". the struggle is real though

mcc

Someday Cosmic DE will get released, and I will switch to Pop!_OS, and then all the problems on my laptop will be because Cosmic DE is an unfinished product rather than because GNOME is a finished product which made design decisions I disagree with, and I will be Happy because the problems with my laptop will be happening for the correct reasons

mcc

Note: I don't mind Snap. I'd rather my OS be using Flatpak, but I mostly use Snap on purpose and I don't specifically object to my applications being installed as Snap. I just want Snap/Flatpak to like… work right.

Kelson

@mcc > I just want Snap/Flatpak to like… work right.

That would be a huge improvement in my experience.

Aaruni Kaushik

@mcc I agree that as an end user you shouldn't have to care about the philosophy of native v/s namespace v/s whatever snap does, you should just be able to trust the OS default to JustWork(tm).

but this is kind of why I have been against this whole snap and flatpak business. I trust my distro, and by extension, the native packages the maintainers have put in the repos to work well in concert with each other.

mcc

@double_a_runi Well, my experience is that the distro maintainers are very, very conservative and always have very old versions of things, and that Homebrew is very high quality and always has new versions of things, so I'm in principle interested in a software distribution system that looks more like Homebrew than apt

Aaruni Kaushik

@mcc wait we have brew on Linux?

anyway yeah, you are describing why I slowly moved from ubuntu -> mint -> arch . ubuntu got annoying, and mint packages were always old. I know arch is a meme, but its been working for me, and I will move to something else when it stops working for me?

mcc

@double_a_runi I was using OS X locally and linux only on servers until quite recently! Then I rapidly abandoned Mac for Windows and then rapidly abandoned Windows for Linux.

But also, yeah, you can use Homebrew on Linux, if you're feeling adventurous… docs.brew.sh/Homebrew-on-Linux

Aaruni Kaushik replied to mcc

@mcc curl to bash to install, looks promising.

sorry I have nothing useful to reply, I've used brew to install lima on macos, so I can have linux in there, but not beyond that. I don't know how it works, and what kind of conflicts it can have.

lynn

@mcc Snaps gave me soooo many problems in 2018 that I stopped using Ubuntu. It was a "Vista" moment for me.

IME I don't have problems with Flatpaks but I don't use them often either

Aaruni Kaushik

@mcc are you attached to gnome, because if not, I would suggest a more consistent DE? (I know I just apologized for replies like this, but gnome is especially pesky in my experience. I have to deal with gnome on my office workstation, and I hate it)

mcc

@double_a_runi I am very picky about margins on interface elements and IMO the ones in GNOME are Good and the ones in KDE and FVWM are Bad . Despite this I may switch to KDE at some point simply because I very much like Qt.

My current plan is to shelter in place until Cosmic lands (see post elsewhere in thread) and if I'm already doing that then switching to Kubuntu only to quickly tear it down again is not a good use of time.

mhoye

@mcc I have never once heard the advice to switch distros come from somebody who wanted to make any effort whatsoever to understand and solve a problem, only from people who want to say they don't have your problem.

I have had success forcibly disabling touchscreens by adding the appropriate module - "usbtouchscreen" I think? to /etc/modules.d/blacklist, but you're I think right to consider this an indignity.

mcc

@mhoye I believe this would probably work, however, I want a touchscreen, which is why I purchased a laptop with a touchscreen

margot

@mcc i HATE this response bc like, you are a pretty seasoned computer user! and most ppl have even more of a huge cost to switching their OS! and ppl who use linux still don’t seem to understand why the average person doesn’t want to get on linux

Neia

@mcc@mastodon.social Yeah, my experience is that changing distros can fix some problems while introducing new ones. Like I went from Debian to Ubuntu and it improved hardware support while causing a number of other issues.

Yanking out snap improved a lot of those issues, as did using MATE rather than GNOME, but that's more futzing about than anyone should have to do.

Risotto

@mcc oh gosh that's wild!

I'm sorry you're one of the lucky people with bugs I can't reproduce :(

Cameron MacLeod

@mcc Depressed chuckle at the replies suggesting things that are far beyond the scope of "thin support system that allows a web browser to run."

Me: "my streetcar keeps getting caught in traffic due to city policies"

Some Linux fans: "Oh I've seen that before, don't worry, just repave the street in a new shape and you'll be all set."

mcc

@stefan_hessbrueggen Well… I guess I don't have any refutation of that

@frueheneuzeit

@mcc I call it the 'emacs gambit', and it works with almost every tech problem. I love Mastodon! ;)

Tom Forsyth

@mcc Honestly sounds like even an Amiga would work better at this task. Good job Linux.

mcc

@TomF To be fair, I'm not aware of anything to suggest AmigaOS would be able to handle S0ix sleep any better. Maybe mandatory S0ix was just a mistake

mcc

@TomF I hear from many Linux users that their laptop runs great as long as they disable sleep-on-lid-close! I don't want to live that way

gkrnours

@mcc I nearly said I didn't have the issue with firefox but I did spend lot of time and struggle to install the non-snap version. Truly a miserable process just to get the package like in most other linux.

Veronica Olsen 🏳️‍🌈🇳🇴🌻

@gkrnours They do at least have deb packages now. I refuse to use snaps.

@mcc

gkrnours

@fabrice @veronica @mcc that deb should be in ubuntu repo. When I use apt I expect to get a deb. Giving me a snap when using apt is a gross exploitation if my trust

Alex P. 👹

@mcc
for problem #2:

there's a gnome plugin called "Grand Theft Focus" that will make its behavior less infuriating

mcc

@saddestrobots Thanks, I'll look into it.

There was a plugin that ameliorated the "touchscreen mode" issue by permanently killing the GNOME on-screen keyboard, but then I upgraded and it stopped working.

Trillion Byter

@mcc @saddestrobots

Lol. *sad trombone*

Every tutorial that includes "just run 'apt upgrade' " infuriates me.

No! I need to fix this one specific issue. Not spend the next 8+ hours figuring out which package upgrades broke my dependency stack and downgrading packages by trial and error.

₲.$.₱₹ᏫĐɄ₡₮łᏫ₦

@mcc@mastodon.social
Oh, yes, I can't say anything about Gnome, because I have Ubuntu. But, yes, we, in MissKey, have some noise through FireFox instead of uploaded pictures to the local disk, and only on JPG, it seems (on PNG there is no pink noise after uploading, I think)! I've already asked our natives to help me with this somehow, but they didn't help me. Well, as Churchill said, "he who chooses security over liberty is worthy of neither!".

Translated with DeepL.com (free version)

Dana Fried

@mcc it took me forever to understand why, when I accidentally pressed CTRL-O instead of ALT-O in VS Code, I got a random popup that said that the application was ready and then it became completely unresponsive.

Turns out it was showing the "open file" dialog *behind* the window, but still somehow making it modal. Because Wayland? I dunno.

Now I at least know how to fix it without having to close and restart Code, but it was driving me absolutely nuts for a while.

Adriano

@tess @mcc Dialogs opening behind vscode under Wayland are one of the things I've missing-staired, and I hate it.

Josh Simmons

@adriano @tess @mcc fwiw i believe it should actually be fixed in vscode now generally. (as of the may release)

Dana Fried

@dotstdy @adriano it's possible I'm not running on the very latest

Update: no, I'm not; corp has us on February release still. Good to know it will eventually be fixed but sheesh.

Josh Simmons

@tess @adriano you might also need to force it to use the wayland backend, but I'm not sure which of the various hacks I have are currently load-bearing for which bugs. :')

margot

@mcc the new window bug baffles me every time it happens, especially bc it’s SO inconsistent. weirdly i have a different bug upon waking up from sleep where everything will work fine except my touchpad won’t work at all unless i reboot

margot

@mcc i think overall tho i’ve had worse weird random bugs with windows (hello, bug which makes my computer decide i don’t have internet anymore until i reboot) that i have a much better opinion on ubuntu as a casual user. nothing really beats early mac os, tho

mcc

@emaytch Sometimes I think I was never happier using a computer than I was using Mac OS 9

margot

@mcc that was definitely the golden era and i assume it has nothing to do with me being young enough to be impressionable at the time

Mr Salteena is not quite a gentleman
@mcc oh lordy the image preview thing. I fixed that by following arcane instructions to get Firefox installed old style from a debian package again via a PPA, rather than Ubuntu's snap and that did the job - at the price of nuking my profile and requiring me to set it all up again. It's infuriating that Ubuntu took the app we probably spend most time with, and preferred to push it into the snap model they advocate at the cost of usability.

If I weren't so pig-headedly committed to FOSS I would be running a Mac for sure.

(said arcane instructions are here https://askubuntu.com/questions/1399383/how-to-install-firefox-as-a-traditional-deb-package-without-snap-in-ubuntu-22/ )
@mcc oh lordy the image preview thing. I fixed that by following arcane instructions to get Firefox installed old style from a debian package again via a PPA, rather than Ubuntu's snap and that did the job - at the price of nuking my profile and requiring me to set it all up again. It's infuriating that Ubuntu took the app we probably spend most time with, and preferred to push it into the snap model they advocate at the cost of usability.
Nire Bryce

@mcc
The windows behind everything might be "focus stealing prevention", i know it is called that on KDE, the worst possible description for it.

I haven't used gnome in a bit for anything but playing around with breezy so I don't know the specifics there though

nepi

@mcc Honestly my linux experience got a lot better after switching to a KDE based distribution. Had endless trouble with GNOME. Looks nice but that’s about it unfortunately.

Tom Forsyth

@mcc This mirrors my experience of Linux, and I was using Ubuntu *inside a VM*. It's the most controlled environment possible - how is it still such a trainwreck?

jjj

@mcc Good to know this is a common bug, just showing a notification at the top. It happens to me when I right click Firefox in the dock (or what it’s called) and click “new window”. Extremely annoying. I very much support apps not hijacking my focus but this is the opposite and just as bad.

Go Up